By the way, "a shounen protagonist" is the protagonist "of" a shounen manga/anime, not a protagonist who "is" a shounen, i.e. not a boy protagonist, a protagonist of a series for boys.
Note: not to be confused with shounen-ai and shoujo-ai, which, in English, refers to gay and lesbian genres of manga and anime.
How to Tell Apart
If you want to know whether an anime is shounen or shoujo, check what manga it's adapted from, and what magazine the manga was serialized on.
For example, Naruto ナルト is a shounen anime, because its manga was serialized on Shounen Jump 少年ジャンプ, which is a shounen magazine.
The content of the anime doesn't matter. The terms aren't genres, they're demographics.
The magazine has its target demographic, so its editors will prefer content that its demographic will like. If a manga is published on Shounen Jump, it's because the editors of the magazine think it's suited for a shounen demographic.
Naturally, the editors whose job is literally to figure this out probably know what they're doing, so there's no point in arguing a manga isn't shounen when it's published in a shounen magazine.
I want to emphasize that if Naruto got published in a shoujo magazine instead, it would have been called a shoujo manga, EVEN IF THE CONTENT WAS THE SAME.
The content doesn't matter at all, it's whom it's marketed to that matters. It just happens that one thing influences the other.
Being the Wrong Audience
Sometimes people ask if it's okay for them to like shounen manga if they aren't children, or shoujo manga if they aren't girls. Of course it's okay.
This is just the audience the magazine is aiming for. If more girls than boys bought a shounen magazine, the magazine would gladly take their money.
In some cases, a manga published in a shounen magazine is more popular with its female readership than with its male readership.
This is specially the case if it's a series that has very few female characters in it, which occurs with sports series like Haikyuu ハイキュー, that has volleyball teams full of male characters, and almost no girls around.
Definition
少年
The word shounen 少年 means "boy," as in an underage male person, so it includes male teenagers. In legal contexts, shounen means anyone underage, e.g.:
- shounen-hou
少年法
Juvenile law.
The kanji of shounen mean literally:
- sukunai
少ない
Few. - toshi
年
Year.
Typically, a shounen series has an underage male protagonist, and they're most about fighting and action.
Often, there's a focus on learning new things, exploring, connecting to new people, and growing as a person, in other words, adventure, bravery, making friends, protecting your nakama 仲間, making rivals, and so on.
The Shounen Jump motto is even:
- yuujou
友情
Friendship. - doryoku
努力
Effort. - shouri
勝利
Victory.
Many shounen series are about starting a new life in a new town, or starting high school, or embarking in an adventure, and so on, placing the protagonist in a situation where he will be alone.
There, he makes new friends. He meets obstacles and enemies that he is able to overcome and defeat with effort.
The whole idea is that effort pays off and friends are great to have.
Unfortunately, the shounen adventure combination tends to yield child protagonists who are orphans because they're supposed to start alone, or whose parents are missing for one reason or another.
Besides this genre, gag manga, comedies, romcoms, are found targeted at a shounen audience.
In particular, the ecchi エッチ genre, which features somewhat erotic drawings, including tropes like panty shots (panchira パンチラ) and lots of fanservice, is also often targeted at a shounen audience, and published in a shounen magazine.
Pornography is obviously restricted to adult audiences, but shounen is any boy under 18, so we aren't talking about little kids here. A series in a shounen magazine could be target a high school audience, for example.
For reference, some examples of shounen manga:
Series | Genre | Lead | Notes | Serialization |
---|---|---|---|---|
One Piece ワンピース |
Adventure. | Boy. | Parents missing. | Shounen Jump 少年ジャンプ |
Hunter x Hunter | Adventure. | Boys. | Parents missing. | Shounen Jump 少年ジャンプ |
Naruto ナルト |
Action. | Boy. | Parents dead. School setting. |
Shounen Jump 少年ジャンプ |
Fullmetal Alchemist Hagane no Renkinjutsushi 鋼の錬金術師 |
Action. | Boys. | Parents dead. | Shounen Gangan 少年ガンガン |
Demon Slayer Kimetsu no Yaiba 鬼滅の刃 |
Action. | Boy. | Parents dead. | Shounen Jump 少年ジャンプ |
Bleach | Action | Boy. | Mother dead. | Shounen Jump 少年ジャンプ |
Soul Eater | Action. | Girl. | Mother dead. School setting. |
Shounen Gangan 少年ガンガン |
Attack on Titan Shingeki no Kyojin 進撃の巨人 |
Action. | Boy. | Parents dead. | (Kodansha's) Shounen Magazine 少年マガジン |
JoJo's Bizarre Adventure JoJo no Kimyou na Bouken ジョジョの奇妙な冒険 |
Bizarre. | Man. | Shounen Jump 少年ジャンプ |
|
Fist of North Star Hokuto no Ken 北斗の拳 |
Action. | Man. | Shounen Jump 少年ジャンプ |
|
Gintama 銀魂 |
Comedy. | Man. | Shounen Jump 少年ジャンプ |
|
Mahou Sensei Negima! 魔法先生ネギま! |
Comedy. | Boy. | School setting. | Shounen Magazine 少年マガジン |
Nichijou 日常 |
Comedy. | Girls. | School setting. | Shounen Ace 少年エース |
Rosario to Vampire ロザリオとバンパイア |
Ecchi. | Boy. | School setting. | Shounen Jump 少年ジャンプ |
To LOVE-Ru To LOVEる |
Ecchi. | Boy. | Shounen Jump 少年ジャンプ |
|
Death Note | Psychological. | Boy. | Shounen Jump 少年ジャンプ |
|
Future Diary Mirai Nikki 未来日記 |
Psychological. | Boy. | Shounen Ace 少年エース |
少女
The word shoujo 少女 means "girl." It's the female counterpart of shounen, so any underage girl, no matter how old, is a shoujo, including high school girls.
As one would expect, shoujo series tend to have a female protagonist where a shounen series would have a male protagonist.
In particular, the harem genre, in which a guy is surrounded by potential girlfriends, is even reversed into a so-called reverse harem genre, in which a girl is surrounded by potential boyfriends.
The shoujo manga are known for their pretty drawings. Girls are drawn like princesses, guys are drawn like princes. Clothes are detailed, eyes are sparkling, and backgrounds are full of flowers.
They're often more emotional, with heavier focus on romance and intrigue.
The "magical girl," mahou shoujo 魔法少女, genre, traditionally targets a shoujo audience, and in this genre some pretty normal and average girl transforms with magic into a cute outfit, much like a Japanese Cinderella.
Some shoujo series target a niche audience called fujoshi 腐女子, "rotten girls," who ship male characters with other male characters. They're in a gay genre called BL in Japanese, and they'll feature pretty boys in fashionable outfits, and the sort.
There are much fewer shoujo anime than shounen anime.
For reference, some examples of shoujo manga:
Series | Genre | Lead | Serialization |
---|---|---|---|
Cardcaptor Sakura カードキャプターさくら |
Magical girl. | Girl. | Nakayoshi なかよし |
Bishoujo Senshi Sailor Moon 美少女戦士セーラームーン |
Magical girl. | Girl. | Nakayoshi なかよし |
Tokyo Mew Mew 東京ミュウミュウ |
Magical girl. | Girl. | Nakayoshi なかよし |
Magic Knight Rayearth 魔法騎士レイアース |
isekai 異世界. | Girls. | Nakayoshi なかよし |
Ouran Koukou Host Club Ouran Koukou Host-bu 桜蘭高校ホスト部刃 |
Reverse harem. | Girl. | LaLa |
Kaichou wa Maid-sama! 会長はメイド様! |
Romcom. | Girl. | LaLa |
Sabage-bu! さばげぶっ! |
Comedy. | Girl. | Nakayoshi なかよし |
Nana | Drama. | Girl. | Cookie |
The Rose of Versailles Versailles no Bara ベルサイユのばら |
Drama. | Girl. | Margaret マーガレット |
Glass no Kamen ガラスの仮面 |
Drama. | Girl. | Hana to Yume 花とゆめ |
Patalliro! パタリロ! |
BL. | Boy. | Hana to Yume 花とゆめ |
青年
The word seinen 青年 means "young adult," but it's typically used to refer to a "young man," rather than to a woman. Not to be confused with the homonymous seinen 成年, which just means "adult," in the sense of not underage.
There are various reasons for a series to be seinen instead of shounen, mainly the fact that it handles more adult themes, which tend to be dark and depressing.
Plot-centered shounen tends to be simple, such that any issue can be solved with perseverance, effort, or power. It's good versus evil. Black and white. While in a seinen the plot tends to be about concession. There will be tragedy, loss, defeat, and no easy solution.
It focuses on the complexities of life and on moving on, about living in society, about having a job, having a family, etc.
A shounen typically feature a high school student or younger as protagonist, while seinen is more likely to feature adults, college age characters.
If a comedy is seinen, it's likely to feature adult jokes.
Sometimes, a series is seinen simply because its themes aren't suitable for minors, like crime, drug abuse, suicide, and so on.
Some seinen series are simply chill and relaxing, the slice of life genre, which may be considered boring for younger readers. In particular, these tend to feature a main cast full of girls, leading them to be called Cute Girls Doing Cute Things in English.
Some of such series can take place on a workplace, or focus on a specific job.
In general, a moe 萌え series is targeted at an older audience that buys blu-rays, which its fans, the otaku オタク, will buy paying with their own money, but children wouldn't afford. Series targeted at younger audiences prefer to sell children toys instead.
There are also several series that are considered seinen because they were originally published as light novels full of text that target an older audience.
An ecchi seinen series is likely to feature some sort of fetishism that a shounen series wouldn't have, and it's likely to have a character trying to get into a sexual relationship with someone, where a shounen would be mostly random nude shots in weird, accidental situations.
For reference, some examples of seinen manga:
Series | Genre | Lead | Notes. | Serialization |
---|---|---|---|---|
Minami-ke みなみけ |
Comedy. | Girls. | Young Magazine ヤングマガジン |
|
Asobi Asobase あそびあそばせ |
Comedy. | Girls. | Young Animal ヤングアニマル |
|
Saki 咲 |
Mahjong. | Girls. | Young Gangan ヤングガンガン |
|
Eizouken ni wa Te wo Dasuna! 映像研には手を出すな! |
Comedy. | Girls. | Spirits スピリッツ |
|
Kaguya-sama wa Kokurasetai かぐや様は告らせたい |
Romcom. | Couple. | Young Jump ヤングジャンプ |
|
Detroit Metal City デトロイト・メタル・シティ |
Comedy. | Man. | Language. | Young Animal ヤングアニマル |
Yondemasu yo, Azazel-san. よんでますよ、アザゼルさん。 |
Comedy. | Woman. | Language. | Evening イブニング |
Prison School 監獄学園 |
Ecchi. | Boy. | Fetishism. | Young Magazine ヤングマガジン |
Nana to Kaoru ナナとカオル |
Ecchi. | Boy. | Fetishism. | Young Animal ヤングアニマル |
Initial D 頭文字D |
Racing. | Boy. | Prostitution. | Young Magazine ヤングマガジン |
Tobaku Mokujiroku Kaiji 賭博黙示録カイジ |
Drama. | Man. | Gambling. | Young Magazine ヤングマガジン |
AKIRA | Drama. | Boy. | Violence. | Young Magazine ヤングマガジン |
Inuyashiki いぬやしき |
Drama. | Man. | Violence. | Evening イブニング |
Tokyo Ghoul 東京喰種 |
Drama. | Man. | Violence. | Young Jump ヤングジャンプ |
Holy Land ホーリーランド |
Drama. | Boy. | Violence. | Young Animal ヤングアニマル |
Berserk ベルセルク |
Suffering. | Man. | Suffering. | Young Animal ヤングアニマル |
女性
The word josei 女性 means a "woman," or the "female gender."
The opposite is dansei 男性, a "man," or the "male gender."
There are exceedingly few josei anime, so it's hard to say what it typically contains, but the basic idea is that it's the more mature variant of shoujo, so it's more likely to have an adult woman as the protagonist.
In Japanese, josei magazines are classified as yangu redhiisu ヤング・レディース, "Young Ladies'," if they target an 18–30 year old audience. A magazine like Flowers, which targets an older than 30 female audience, would be josei but not Young Ladies'.
Just like some seinen series are about cute anime girls, some josei series are about cute anime boys.
They aren't strictly BL if the protagonists don't actually get into a homosexual romantic relationship, but the series may portray more emotional relationships between male characters that one might say "looks pretty gay" compared to how male characters are normally portrayed in anime.
Some examples of josei manga include:
Series | Genre | Lead | Notes. | Serialization |
---|---|---|---|---|
Kids on the Slope Sakamichi no Apollon 坂道のアポロン |
Drama. | Boys. | Love triangles. | Flowers |
Chihayafuru ちはやふる |
Romance. | Girl. | Love triangle. | BE・LOVE |
Usagi Drop うさぎドロップ |
Drama. | Man. | Parenthood. | FEEL YOUNG |
Kuragehime 海月姫 |
Romcom. | Woman. | Female otaku. | Kiss |
Gokusen ごくせん |
Comedy. | Woman. | Female teacher. | YOU |
LOVELESS | Drama. | Boy. | Practically BL. | ZERO-SUM |
Jingai-san no Yome 人外さんの嫁 |
Comedy. | Boy. | Boys as brides. | ZERO-SUM |
向け
To say to whom a thing is marketed in Japanese, the word muke 向け is used. For example:
- shounen-muke
少年向け
Targeted at boys. - shoujo-muke
少女向け
Targeted at girls. - seinen-muke
青年向け
Targeted at young adults. - josei-muke
女性向け
Targeted at women.
It's the noun form of the verb mukeru 向ける, which means "to point at" or "to face" something.
- nakama ni ken wo mukeru tsumori ka?
仲間に剣を向けるつもりか?
Are [you] going to point [your] sword at [your] friends?
Easiness to Read
For those learning Japanese, it's a better idea to read shounen and shoujo manga instead of seinen and josei manga.
The manga targeted at children have furigana ふりがな in almost every word, that is, they include how the kanji are supposed to be read, so you don't have to guess or look it up. The manga meant for adults only have furigana in kanji that rarely show up, like those for names of animals.
By the way, if you're searching for your first manga to read in Japanese, try Yotsubato! よつばと! It's very easy to read with big letters, easy words and easy dialogue.
Very nice roundup, and not as superficial as some others. The only thing I disagree with is preferring manga with furigana for learning Japanese. Originally I thought like that, too, but eventually I realized that, after all, furigana are primarily *reading* aids rather than *learning* aids. Since there is practically no “cost” to looking up the readings, and taking the readings to look up the meaning in a dictionary is pretty “low-cost” as well, there is no need for my brain to memorize anything. When reading manga without furigana, I can (usually) figure out the readings and meanings with a dictionary anyway and coming across the same word just two or three times is often enough for me to learn it.
ReplyDeleteLoved this.. :) I've learned a lot in just one page. Now I can certainly enjoy reading my mangas more! Thanks!
ReplyDeleteCan i ask on what category does an anime/manga Hanebado falls in? It reminds me of a shonen type but obviously its not shonen... Please enlighten me. Thanks.
ReplyDeleteLooks like the manga was serialized in a seinen magazine (Good! Afternoon). So it should be seinen.
Delete